Listing Provided Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Naples
Designed as a forever home, this fully renovated modern farmhouse in Spanish Wells blends impeccable craftsmanship, elevated finishes, and inviting indoor–outdoor living. From the book matched waterfall quartzite island and custom walnut bar to the spa-like primary wet room and serene lake and golf course views, every detail was intentionally curated for both beauty and function. This single-story 3-bedroom, 3-bath home in Spanish Wells Golf & Country Club offers 2,372 sq ft under air and was completely reimagined with openness, flow, and high-end finishes throughout. There are expansive entertaining spaces, featuring cathedral ceilings in the great room, vaulted beams in the secondary living area, and layered LED lighting—all on dimmers for a warm, refined ambiance. The chef’s kitchen and custom bar anchor the home, showcasing semi-custom cabinetry with soft-close doors and under cabinet lighting, rollouts, hidden trash, and a panel-ready dishwasher. Quartz and honed quartzite countertops elevate the space, while the oversized island provides ample prep space and area to gather. Appliances include a GE Café range and refrigerator, Bosch dishwasher, Wolf microwave drawer, and a standout custom walnut bar with floating LED-lit shelves, a Thermador 58-bottle wine fridge, concealed refrigerator drawers, and wood burning fireplace to compliment the mood. All bathrooms feature walk-in showers with porcelain tile and custom niches. The primary suite is a true spa retreat with a custom wet room, dual shower heads, freestanding soaking tub, large-format 4’x4’ tile, handheld, and backlit mirrors. 12″ porcelain wood-plank tile runs throughout the home, complemented by 8” baseboards, single panel shaker doors, and thoughtful design details at every turn. Outdoor living shines with a covered lanai, full outdoor bar with sink and refrigerator drawers, new pavers and tile (2024), custom water feature, and brand-new pool heater (2026). Enjoy tranquil lake and golf course views of the 5th hole on the North Course, surrounded by upgraded landscaping. Built-in hurricane shutters—including electric sliders and windows—make storm prep effortless. Additional highlights include whole-home Sonos surround sound, smart thermostat, full plumbing re-pipe to PEX (2019), new AC (2024) relocated to the garage, and an oversized two-car garage with epoxy floors and newly installed hurricane impact garage door (2026). HOA dues under $250/month include cable, internet, sewer, and trash. Centrally located just minutes from beaches, dining, shopping, downtown Bonita Springs, and RSW Airport, this home offers a rare blend of design-forward style and everyday functionality—perfect for entertaining and refined Florida living. Skip the dust, decisions, and disruption. Every detail of this completely
reimagined residence has been carefully renovated so you don’t have to. Just turn the key and step into your beautifully finished home designed for modern living.
reimagined residence has been carefully renovated so you don’t have to. Just turn the key and step into your beautifully finished home designed for modern living.
Property Details
Price:
$1,250,000
MLS #:
226006996
Status:
Active
Beds:
3
Baths:
3
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
SPANISH WELLS
Neighborhood:
spanishwells
Listed Date:
Feb 19, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
2,372
Total Sq Ft:
2,900
Lot Size:
12,197 sqft / 0.28 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1984
See this Listing
Schools
Interior
Appliances
Electric Cooktop, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Freezer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Refrigerator/Freezer, Refrigerator/Icemaker, Self Cleaning Oven, Steam Oven, Washer, Wine Cooler
Bathrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Ceiling Fan(s), Central Electric
Flooring
Tile
Heating
Central Electric
Laundry Features
Washer/Dryer Hookup, Laundry in Residence, Laundry Tub
Exterior
Architectural Style
Ranch, Single Family
Association Amenities
Bocce Court, Business Center, Clubhouse, Pool, Fitness Center, Golf Course, Internet Access, Pickleball, Private Membership, Restaurant, Shopping, Streetlight, Tennis Court(s)
Community Features
Clubhouse, Pool, Fitness Center, Golf, Restaurant, Street Lights, Tennis Court(s), Gated
Construction Materials
Concrete Block, Stucco
Exterior Features
Screened Lanai/Porch, Outdoor Kitchen
Other Structures
Tennis Court(s), Outdoor Kitchen
Parking Features
Driveway Paved, Attached
Parking Spots
2
Roof
Tile
Security Features
Smoke Detector(s), Gated Community
Financial
HOA Fee
$2,963
Tax Year
2025
Taxes
$7,918
Map
Community
- Address9956 Treasure Cay LN BONITA SPRINGS FL
- SubdivisionSPANISH WELLS
- CityBONITA SPRINGS
- CountyLee
- Zip Code34135
Subdivisions in BONITA SPRINGS
- ACREAGE
- ADDISON PLACE
- ALTAIRA
- ALTESSA
- AMBASSADOR CONDO
- AMBERLEY COURT
- ANCHORAGE AT BONITA BAY
- AREZZO
- AROYAL PINES
- ARROYAL
- ARROYAL HEIGHTS
- ASHMONT
- AURORA CONDOMINIUMS
- AZURE
- BABCOCK NATIONAL
- BAREFOOT BAY
- BAREFOOT BEACH
- BAREFOOT BEACH CLUB
- BAY CEDAR
- BAY HARBOR
- BAY HARBOR CLUB CONDO
- BAY POINTE AT BONITA BAY
- BAY VIEW II
- BAY WOODS
- BAYCREST
- BAYFRONT GARDENS
- BAYVIEW AT BONITA BAY
- BEACH AND TENNIS CLUB
- BELL VILLA
- BELLA VITA
- BELLINO
- BERMUDA CAYS
- BERMUDA CAYS CONDO
- BERMUDA GARDENS
- BERMUDA ISLES
- BERMUDA LAGO
- BERMUDA LINKS
- BERMUDA PARK
- BERMUDA POINTE
- BONITA BEACH
- BONITA BEACH CLUB
- BONITA BEACH PLANTATION HOUSE
- BONITA BEACH TRAILER PARK
- BONITA BEACHWALK
- BONITA COUNTRY CLUB
- BONITA DEL SOL
- BONITA FARMS
- BONITA GOLF CLUB VILLAS
- BONITA ISLES
- BONITA LAKES
- BONITA LANDING
- BONITA NATIONAL GOLF AND COUNTRY CLUB
- BONITA PARK
- BONITA PINES
- BONITA ROYAL CONDO PHASE 1
- BONITA SHORES
- BONITA SPRINGS
- BONITA SPRINGS GOLF & COUNTRY CLUB
- BONITA SPRINGS VILLAGE GARDENS CONDO
- BONITA ST JAMES VILLAGE
- BONITA VILLAGE
- BOTANIKA
- BRENDAN COVE
- BRIDGEWATER
- BROOKSIDE ESTATES
- BURNING TREE
- CARAVELLA
- CARMEL
- CAROLANDS
- CARRIAGE HOMES AT WOODS EDGE
- CARTWRIGHTS SUBDIVISION
- CASA BONITA GRANDE
- CASA BONITA I
- CASA BONITA II
- CASA BONITA ROYALE
- CASSIA
- CASTELLA
- CAVENDISH COURT
- CEDAR CREEK
- CERCINA
- CHESAPEAKE COVE
- CIELO AT THE COLONY
- CITADEL EAST
- CITADEL SOUTH
- CITADEL WEST
- COBBLESTONE
- COCKLESHELL VILLAGE
- COCONUT GROVE
- COLONY
- CORAL WOODS SUBDIVISION
- CORDERA
- CORDOVA AT SPANISH WELLS
- COSTA DEL SOL
- COTTAGES
- COTTAGES AT PELICAN LANDING
- CRACKER COVE
- CRANBROOK
- CREEKSIDE
- CREEKSIDE CROSSING
- CROSSINGS
- CYPRESS PLANTATIONS
- CYPRESS PLANTATIONS CONDO
- CYPRESS PRESERVE
- DIAMOND RIDGE
- DOLPHIN COVE
- DOLPHIN WAY
- EAGLES NEST
- EDENBRIDGE GARDENS
- EGRETS LANDING
- EL DORADO ACRES
- EMORY OAKS
- ESPERIA SOUTH
- ESTANCIA
- ESTERO BAY SHORES
- FAIRWAY DUNES CONDO
- FAIRWAY ESTATES
- FAIRWAY PINES CONDO
- FAIRWINDS
- FIRENZE
- FLORENCIA
- FOREST MERE TOWNHOUSE COMMUNITY
- GARDENS AT BERMUDA LINKS
- GARDENS OF BONITA SPRINGS
- GLEN MANOR
- GOLDCREST
- GOLF VILLAS OF BONITA SPRINGS
- GREENBRIAR
- GREENS AT BONITA SPRINGS
- GREYHOUND COMMERCE PARK
- GULF HARBOR
- GULL HAVEN
- HACIENDA EAST
- HACIENDA VILLAGE
- HARBOR LAKES
- HARBOR LANDING
- HAWTHORNE
- HEATHERMOOR
- HEITMANS
- HELFENSTEIN ESTATES
- HERON COVE AT PELICAN LANDING
- HERON GLEN
- HERON POINT
- HICKORY BAY WEST
- HICKORY HARBOUR
- HIDDEN HARBOR
- HIDDEN LAKES AT WOODS EDGE
- HIDEAWAY COVE
- HIGHLAND WOODS
- HORIZONS
- HUNTERS RIDGE
- IBIS COVE AT BONITA BAY
- IMPERIAL BONITA ESTATES
- IMPERIAL GATES
- IMPERIAL HARBOR
- IMPERIAL RIVER ESTATES
- IMPERIAL SHORES
- INFINITY AT THE COLONY
- IRISH PINES
- ISLAND BEACH CLUB CONDO
- LA SCALA AT THE COLONY
- LA TREMITI
- LAKE CLUB VILLAS
- LAKE POINTE
- LAKEMONT
- LAKEMONT COVE
- LAKES OF SAN SOUCI
- LAKESIDE HIDEAWAY
- LAS BRISAS AT SPANISH WELLS
- LAUREL RIDGE
- LEDFORD SHORES
- LEISURE TIME CAMPSITES
- LEITNER CREEK MANOR
- LIGHTHOUSE BAY
- LIMETREE PARK
- LITTLE HICKORY BAY
- LITTLE HICKORY SHORES
- LONGLAKE
- LONGLAKE VILLAGE
- LOVERS KEY BEACH CLUB
- LYNX PASS
- MANGO CREEK
- MANOR
- MARBELLA
- MARBELLA AT SPANISH WELLS
- MATERA
- MEADOWLARK ESTATES
- MOBILE VILLAS
- MORTON GROVE
- MOUND KEY MOBILE HAVEN
- MYSTIC RIDGE
- NATURA
- NAVONA AT THE COLONY
- NOVELA
- NUTTINGLIKIT GROVE
- OAK RIDGE
- OAKLAND ACRES TRAILER PARK
- OAKWOOD
- OAKWOOD CARRIAGE HOME
- OAKWOOD VILLAS
- OHLMAN ACRES
- OMEGA AT BONITA BAY
- ORANGE CREEK
- ORANGE GROVE TRAILER PARK
- PALERMO
- PALM COLONY
- PALOMA
- PARADISE VILLAGE
- PARK PLACE
- PELICAN POINTE CONDO
- PELICAN RIDGE
- PIENZA
- PINE HAVEN CONDO
- PIRATE’S COVE II
- PIRATES COVE
- POINTE AT PELICAN LANDING
- POLYNESIAN VILLAS
- PRESERVE IN BONITA
- PUESTA DEL LAGO
- QUAIL CREEK
- QUAIL WALK
- RESERVE AT PELICAN LANDING
- RICHVIEW
- RIO VISTA UNRECORDED SUBDIVISION
- RIVERDALE
- RIVERSIDE
- RIVERWALK
- RIVIERA AT BONITA BAY
- RIVIERA COLONY
- ROOKERY LAKE
- ROSEMARY PARK
- ROSEWOOD POINTE GARDEN
- SAMANNS IN BONITA SPRINGS
- SAN CARLOS ESTATES
- SAN MIRAGE
- SAN REMO
- SANCTUARY
- SANCTUARY AT WULFERT
- SANDPIPER AT BONITA BAY
- SANDPIPER GREENS
- SANDPIPER ISLE
- SAWGRASS POINT
- SEA ISLES
- SEAGLASS AT BONITA BAY
- SEASCAPE
- SEASCAPE CONDO
- SEASONS AT BONITA
- SERRANO
- SHANNONS
- SHORE WOODS
- SIENA
- SIR MICHAELS PLACE
- SOLENZARA
- SOLIS GRANDE
- SORRENTO
- SOUTHBRIDGE
- SOUTHERN PINES
- SOUTHPORT ON THE BAY
- SPANISH GARDENS
- SPANISH HARBOR
- SPANISH WELLS
- SPRING CREEK ESTATES
- SPRING CREEK VILLAGE
- SPRING LAKES
- ST ANDREWS VERANDAS
- SUDBURY ESTATES
- SUN COAST ACRES
- SUN VILLAGE ESTATES
- SUNSET ACRES
- TARPON BEND
- TARPON BEND UNREC
- TAVIRA
- TERRACE I
- TERRACE III
- TERRACE IV
- TERZETTO
- THE CARLYSLE
- THE EGRET
- THE ENCLAVE
- THE ENCLAVE OF DISTINCTION
- THE HAMPTONS
- THE RITZ-CARLTON RESIDENCES ESTERO BAY
- THOMAS ESTATES
- TOSCANA
- TRIESTE
- TRIESTE PRESERVE
- TROPIC ACRES
- TUCKAWEYE
- VALENCIA BONITA
- VANDERBILT LAKES
- VILLA BONITA
- VILLA D’ESTE
- VILLA MAR BONITA BEACH
- VILLA TUSCANY
- VILLAGE WALK OF BONITA SPRINGS
- VILLAGES OF BONITA
- VILLAS
- VILLAS AT BAREFOOT BEACH
- VISTAS AT BONITA BAY
- WATERFORD AT BONITA BAY
- WATERFORD AT WORTHINGTON
- WATERSIDE
- WEDGEWOOD
- WEDGEWOOD AT BONITA BAY
- WEDGEWOOD AT WORTHINGTON
- WEDGEWOOD FOUNTAIN
- WEDGEWOOD SHERBURNE
- WHISKEY POINTE
- WILD PINES
- WILDWOOD PRESERVE
- WINDSONG
- WOODLAKE AT BONITA BAY
- WOODS EDGE
- WORTHINGTON
- WORTHINGTON WAY
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in BONITA SPRINGS as of Mar 06, 2026
627
Single Family Listed
108
Avg DOM
554
Avg $ / SqFt
$1,574,723
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the SPANISH WELLS subdivision, 9956 Treasure Cay LN BONITA SPRINGS FL is a Single Family for sale in BONITA SPRINGS, FL, 34135. It is listed for $1,250,000 and features 3 beds, 3 baths, and has approximately 2,372 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1984. The current price per square foot is $527. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in BONITA SPRINGS is $554. The average listing price for Single Family in BONITA SPRINGS is $1,574,723. To schedule a showing of MLS#226006996 at 9956 Treasure Cay LN in BONITA SPRINGS, FL, contact your Century 21 Carioti agent at 2392986550.
Similar Listings Nearby
9956 Treasure Cay LN
BONITA SPRINGS, FL

